Which RHOSLC Wife Brought the Cucumber on the BDDU Charter?

It was a Bravoverse first when The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City Season 6 cast joined the Below Deck Down Under Season 4 crew for a trip to sea. In the aftermath of the explosive fights, injuries, and seasickness, one question remained: Who packed a cucumber in their luggage?

To recap: When the ‘Wives first boarded the superyacht in Episode 7, stewardess Jenna Woudberg was unpacking luggage and discovered a cucumber in a suitcase, causing gossip about who put it there (and why!) among the Housewives and the yacht crew.

Viewers finally got an answer during Peacock’s extended and uncensored version of Part 1 of the RHOSLC reunion when host Andy Cohen posed the question, and Whitney Rose raised her hand. Mary Cosby simultaneously pointed at Whitney and declared, “This one!”

Andy asked Whitney for more “backstory,” and she happily delivered.

“So there’s a little market right before we boarded the boat, and Heather [Gay] and I went in to get snacks for our room,” Whitney began. “And I just saw it, and I was like, ‘Oh my gosh, I’m going to play a prank on Heather.’ So I grab the cucumber, and my intention was to put it in her bag, and tell them to unpack her bag, but we never had time to do it, so I had to just own it.”

Heather joked that the prank “backfired” on Whitney, but Mary questioned why Whitney chose a cucumber.

“Because it would be funny. It’s a funny prank to do to your best friend,” Whitney said. “The vegetables there were fascinating. They were like short and fat.”

Heather revealed that Lisa Barlow was the original target for the prank. “Remember…we were just going to put something like handcuffs or something funny in her suitcase,” Heather said. “We had a good time.”

How to see more of the RHOSLC charter on Below Deck Down Under Season 4

Andy pointed out to the ‘Wives during the supersized Peacock episode that the “reverse point of view” of the historic charter will soon air on Below Deck Down Under Season 4, and asked if they were “worried.”  

“Should we be?” Lisa asked in return.

Heather wasn’t fazed: “We are fun guests, and we loved the food and activities,” she said.

As for the screaming dinner fights and stuffed unicorn thrown overboard, Britani Bateman joked, “We have perfect decorum.”

Andy also asked the ‘Wives what it was “like being on another show’s turf.”

Heather answered that it wasn’t all that different from filming RHOSLC. “Andy, we don’t notice cameras anymore, whether it’s production crews — like we were just on a trip. I didn’t even realize that they were shooting their own show,” she explained.

RELATED: How Much Did the RHOSLC Cast Tip the BDDU Crew After Their Chaotic Charter? Heather Gay Says…

ICYMI, Whitney revealed what the BDDU crew had to replace after the RHOSLC cast “destroyed” it during an exclusive Bravo HQ interview.