Though Erin Lichy’s friend Lindsay Hubbard just made her first appearance on The Real Housewives of New York City Season 16, her close bond with the Summer House cast member is hardly a new development.
Indeed, Lindsay was already well-acquainted with Erin when she attended Jessel Taank’s birthday party in Episode 11 of RHONY, but she still had plenty of tea to catch up on amidst all the drama swirling within the cast.
In fact, the bulk of Lindsay’s time in the Nov. 17 episode was spent separate from Erin, while she weighed in on Erika Hammond’s “f–k you gift” for Daisy Toye, as she had described the former’s presentation of a memory supplement during the bash, and also spent time chatting with Carole Radziwill. Even so, a preview for Episode 12 revealed that Lindsay will return to RHONY for a one-on-one with Erin.
In the meantime, read on for more details on Lindsay and Erin’s friendship timeline and what brought them closer together.
How did Lindsay Hubbard and Erin Lichy become friends?
Erin previously explained during an Instagram Q&A in August 2025 that she became friends with Lindsay “years ago” after the Summer House cast member met one of her close pals at a wedding.
“They wound up swapping dresses in [the] bathroom and became friendly,” Erin wrote in a post to her Instagram Stories, at the time. “When we figured that out, we all went to dinner, and we’ve been friends ever since. We got closer since she became a mom!”
RELATED: RHONY Midseason Trailer Teases Hailey Breaking Down, Lindsay Hubbard Cameo & Affair Rumors
How motherhood strengthened Lindsay Hubbard and Erin Lichy’s friendship
Erin and husband Abe Lichy welcomed their fourth child, Jack, in March 2025, just three months after Lindsay became a first-time mom to her daughter, Gemma, in December 2024. The two even posed together for a photo with their infants at an NYC brunch celebrating Jack, shortly after Erin gave birth.
Following an August 2025 playdate in the Hamptons, Lindsay joked about her daughter and Erin’s youngest son getting married one day, in the text overlay of an Instagram Reel, writing, “The summer Gemma found her future husband.” In the caption, she added, “We can’t wait to be [mothers-in-law].”
Afterward, Erin reflected on her and Lindsay’s summer in the Hamptons and how they’d bonded over motherhood, in an October 2025 interview with Decider.
“I really loved our time [together],” Erin told the outlet. “My older kids went to sleepaway camp this summer, so it was just me, her, and her babies the summer when she would come out east. So that was really fun. It’s cute. It’s interesting going through it with somebody else who’s on reality TV. It’s a different experience.”
Erin Lichy weighs in on Lindsay Hubbard’s dating life
Naturally, Erin has had opinions on Lindsay’s dating life over the years, revealing to Us Weekly in December 2025 exactly what kind of man she thought her single friend should date.
At the time, Erin described Lindsay’s ideal match as “a really confident man that doesn’t get spooked by her drive and her presence and just can handle her.”
RELATED: Are Lindsay Hubbard and Joe Bradley from Below Deck Med Dating? She Says…
Is Lindsay Hubbard joining Erin Lichy as a RHONY cast member?
As Lindsay explained at Bravo Fan Fest 2026, her current work commitments are her priority. However, she wouldn’t rule out joining the RHONY cast in the future. “I love my RHONY girls. Erin is one of my best friends. We talk every single day. I’m also close with Jessel and Carole and Daisy,” Lindsay said on a panel. “Sometimes rumors are rumors. Do I hope that maybe one day there’s that trajectory? Sure.”
In March 2025, Erin told Us Weekly that she believed her friend would “be great, to be honest.”
Months later, in an August 2025 interview with Parade, Lindsay shared that she and Erin had actually discussed the possibility of her coming on RHONY. “I think our friendship is just really natural,” Lindsay shared. “So, yeah, do we talk about crossover stuff? We talk about it all the time.”
Noting that she and Erin are “always scheming something,” Lindsay added that they were “currently scheming how to hang out all the time with our babies.”
As Lindsay and Erin continue to share their friendship on Bravo, don’t miss details on where RHONY is filmed.
