HomeCrime'Validly appointed' Jack Smith slams Cannon's 'outlier ruling,' asks court to throw...

'Validly appointed' Jack Smith slams Cannon's 'outlier ruling,' asks court to throw out senator's 'unsupported' lawsuit over Arctic Frost probe

Jack Smith, Aileen Cannon

Left: Former Justice Department special counsel Jack Smith testifies before the Senate Judiciary Committee at the Capitol, Tuesday, Sept. 29, 2026, in Washington. (AP Photo/Allison Robbert). Right: Judge Aileen Cannon (U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida).

To defeat Sen. Marsha Blackburn’s lawsuit over the Arctic Frost investigation, Jack Smith filed a declaration in court, offered to testify and defended the validity of his appointment as special counsel.

According to Smith’s motion to dismiss, filed Thursday in Nashville, Tennessee, the Republican senator sued him in the wrong jurisdiction and, in any event, failed to state a claim.

“Plaintiff’s claims rest on a single, unsupported premise: that Mr. Smith, holding a defective title, acted ‘in his personal capacity’ as a private actor, rather than as a government official carrying out the duties of the United States and protected by various immunities,” the filing said. “This premise fails for two independent reasons. First, Mr. Smith was validly appointed; Plaintiff’s Appointments Clause theory cannot support the relief she seeks against him. Second, regardless of the validity of his appointment, Mr. Smith is absolutely—or, at minimum, qualifiedly—immune from Plaintiff’s damages claims.”

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

Blackburn filed the lawsuit in late September, referring to Smith as a former “Special Counsel.”

Represented by the New Civil Liberties Alliance, Blackburn asked the court to declare that Smith was unlawfully appointed, just as U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon did when throwing out President Donald Trump’s Mar-a-Lago prosecution.

She alleged that Smith conspired with “DOJ, FBI, SCO [Special Counsel’s Office] and employees of the same to injure Senator Blackburn in person or property because of her support of and advocacy for Donald Trump” — by subpoenaing her “toll records” as part of the Jan. 6 investigation.

Shortly thereafter, the active district court judges recused themselves, and the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals designated U.S. District Judge Douglas R. Cole to handle the lawsuit in Smith’s former stomping grounds.

Smith’s declaration emphasized “former” when arguing that the lawsuit should be thrown out for lack of personal jurisdiction. Though he served as the acting U.S. attorney there, he hasn’t lived in Tennessee for three years, court documents said.

“This Court need not reach the merits, as it lacks personal jurisdiction over Mr. Smith, and venue is improper. Plaintiff also lacks standing to seek the equitable relief she requests, leaving only nominal damages, from which Mr. Smith is immune,” Smith’s dismissal motion said. “Were the Court nevertheless to reach the merits, the Complaint fails to state a claim.”

According to Smith, the only “outlier” here was Cannon’s ruling that he was unlawfully appointed as special counsel.

“Every court to consider the question has upheld the Attorney General’s authority to appoint a special counsel, with a singular exception: the district court decision Plaintiff invokes. (citing United States v. Trump, 740 F. Supp. 3d 1245, 1253 (S.D. Fla. 2024)),” the filing added. “That outlier ruling misread the relevant statutes, was on appeal when the case ended, and has never been adopted by any other court. It was also issued more than a year after the subpoena at issue here.”

Nearly a year before Blackburn sued, Smith responded publicly through legal counsel to “correct inaccurate assertions” made by Republican lawmakers that he “tapped” their phones or “spied” on them.

“As you know, toll records merely contain telephonic routing information — collected after the calls have taken place — identifying incoming and outgoing call numbers, the time of the calls, and their duration. Toll records are historical in nature, and do not include the content of calls. Wiretapping, by contrast, involves intercepting the telecommunications in real time, which the Special Counsel’s Office did not do,” he explained.

The post ‘Validly appointed’ Jack Smith slams Cannon’s ‘outlier ruling,’ asks court to throw out senator’s ‘unsupported’ lawsuit over Arctic Frost probe first appeared on Law & Crime.

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -

Most Popular

- Advertisment -
Share on Social Media