Background: Jennifer Nicole Heathcoe (WALA). Inset: Taylor Rawlins (Radney Funeral Home).
A 34-year-old Alabama woman admitted to killing her boyfriend while his kids were inside their apartment, walking back her self-defense claim after the transcript of an incriminating 911 call emerged.
Jennifer Nicole Heathcoe was sentenced to 20 years behind bars after she pleaded guilty to intentional murder Monday in the death of 33-year-old Taylor Rawlins. She was originally facing a capital murder charge and was set to go on trial this week.
Heathcoe fatally stabbed Rawlins in the chest on Aug. 22, 2024, at Charleston Apartments in Mobile.
She initially pleaded not guilty, and her lawyer claimed after her arrest that the defendant was in a “tumultuous” and “violent relationship,” leaving her feeling she had no choice but to defend herself with a knife.
Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.
Her father, Donald Cain, also said, “It was self-defense.”
“Every time I saw her for the last couple of times she was with him for about a year, it’s just gone bad for her,” he said, local CBS affiliate WKRGÂ reported.
But the self-defense claims unraveled.
Rawlins’ 9-year-old daughter, in a desperate bid to save her father, called 911 from her room and initially identified Heathcoe, her stepmom, as the one who stabbed him, according to call transcript details reported by local Fox affiliate WALA.
“My stepmom stabbed my dad,” the girl reportedly said. “[P]lease come quick! My daddy is gonna die.”
Moments later, Heathcoe was heard on the call coaching the girl to blame the stabbing on someone other than her.
District Attorney Keith Blackwood told WALA that Heathcoe appeared to be “telling the child that’s calling to say that it wasn’t her” in order to “minimize [Heathcoe’s] involvement in this murder case,” potentially indicating “consciousness of guilt,” not justified self-defense.
Heathcoe also called 911 that night and said that there was a “dispute” prior to the stabbing.
“Yes, there was just this uh, a dispute and … I got you baby. I got you. Breathe for me,” Heathcoe allegedly said as Rawlins died, before suggesting someone else stabbed him.
“They ran out immediately,” the defendant said.
An obituary for Rawlins said that he had a “boundless love and devotion” for his two children, a “deep connection to his mother,” as her only child, and had a “vibrant personality, sharp humor, and warm laughter [which] brought comfort and joy to everyone around him.”
“In honor of his memory, we encourage others to engage in conversations about domestic violence awareness, understanding that every small action can contribute to a safer world for families and individuals alike,” the obituary said.
Matt Naham contributed to this report
The post ‘My daddy is gonna die’: Woman who fatally stabbed boyfriend and asked his 9-year-old daughter to lie for her is headed to prison first appeared on Law & Crime.
