After a series of deck team errors throughout the first three charters of the season, Captain Kerry Titheradge reached the end of his rope with bosun Alex Wright. “Alex’s mistakes have become more frequent, and it’s getting to a point, I need to make a change,” Kerry ominously declared to producers during Below Deck Season 13, Episode 6. A difficult docking proved to be Kerry’s final straw, and while he decided against outright firing Alex, Kerry did demote him to lead deckhand on the M/Y Azul V crew.
“I’ve lost faith in you. I still want you on the team. But I can’t have you as bosun anymore,” Kerry told him during Below Deck’s Nov. 16 episode. Kerry added, “I do respect you. And I do appreciate you. You understand from my side, I need to know that my bosun has my back.”
But Alex’s demotion also came with a twist, as Kerry then decided to promote Matthew Fitzpatrick-Buck from lead deckhand to bosun. “If I was in the Mediterranean or Caribbean, there’d be crew a short flight away. I’m on the other side of the world in Thailand. I’ve gotta be proactive,” Kerry explained of his unusual decision.
Kerry admitted he did have “reservations” about the position switch-up. “Matt has been bosun in the past. He’s very good at his job,” he said. “But, he’s arrogant. And if I’m able to bring out his initiative, and get some ego away from the position, he’s be a fantastic bosun.”
Kerry cautioned Matt and Alex that for the new arrangement to work, they’d had to learn to work together. After a series of clashes between Matt and Alex, the two hinted that might be a tall order.
“I’m the boss now. I’ve been f—king waiting for this day,” Matt told producers, then added a jab against Alex. “I was going to say big shoes need to be filled, but that’s not f—king true at all, so.”
Why did Captain Kerry Titheradge demote Alex Wright on Below Deck Season 13?
Demoting Alex as bosun wasn’t a position Kerry took lightly, and he began hinting at making “changes” to the deck team even during the Oct. 26 episode. Kerry’s worries worsened during the Nov. 16 episode, after Alex decided to leave a jet ski out in the water overnight.
“I’m pretty pissed off. You never leave a jet ski out overnight. Jet skis are easily stolen. Also, they are prone to sink,” Kerry explained.
But it was a docking that Kerry described as “like a f—king dog’s breakfast” that solidified his decision to demote Alex. As the team was getting ready to dock, stew Rosa Simms-Preston alerted everyone that the hooks for the fenders didn’t fit. Despite deckhand James Bishop’s call for more fender hooks on the radio, Alex neglected to help the team.
“He’s still f—king standing there!” Kerry angrily exclaimed.
After docking, Kerry again told Alex the correct fender hooks were missing, and Alex eventually admitted, “They may have got mixed around.”
“Are you f—king kidding me? I don’t need that layer of bulls—t,” Kerry complained to producers. “Alex just needs to make sure everything’s in place. Where is he?” He concluded, “This program is not supporting Alex’s style as a bosun.”
During the tip meeting, Kerry pointed out that Alex’s error was a safety issue. “Fenders not being in place, things going on, I’m getting distracted from what I need to do. That’s the time that I just need to focus on my job,” he said.
RELATED: “Shady” Below Deck Charter Guest Gives Crew Scathing Feedback: “What the F—k Was That About?
Why Matt Fitzpatrick-Buck argued he should replace Alex Wright as bosun on Below Deck Season 13
Matt’s personal and professional frustrations with Alex piled up during the Nov. 16 episode, and he didn’t hold back with producers. “I’m mad because it’s a f—king build up over the last two or three weeks,” he explained. “Waking up this morning with the boat a f—king mess, I’m sick and tired of running around cleaning up. I’m f—king over it. Enough is enough.”
Matt decided to lay out his case to be named bosun to Captain Kerry. “I’m getting frustrated. I respect Alex as a person, but I keep on picking up his slack and it’s pissing me off,” Matt told him. “Last night, he didn’t give James a job list, and there’s like s—t tons of stuff to do. Two days on deck he’s been late…I just don’t respect him as a bosun.”
RELATED: Below Deck Guests Hit the Crew With a Whopping 20 Complaints in 24 Hours: “Nightmare”
Matt warned if something didn’t change, he was “gonna burn out soon,” and Kerry took his concerns seriously. “If what Matt is telling me is true, it’s totally valid, and I’d be pissed off too. This is not good,” he told producers.
It was then that Kerry began to consider making a switch. “Alex is a little too laid back. I do see Alex doesn’t work as efficient as Matt,” he admitted. “Matt knows what he’s doing. He’s confident. He’s assertive. He’s a bit of an a—hole—he’s got a big ego…The trick is to make it draw performance, not drama.”
As Matt and Alex switch deck positions, check out our guide on how rankings work on Below Deck boats that includes an explanation of hierarchy.
