HomeCrimeICE offered 'ridiculous' excuse for rearresting man just released from detention and...

ICE offered 'ridiculous' excuse for rearresting man just released from detention and was in 'clear contempt' of court: Judge

Donald Trump, Markwayne Mullin

President Donald Trump speaks as he visits the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool to see the new blue protective coating being applied as part of a renovation project, Thursday, May 7, 2026, in Washington, as Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin listens (AP Photo/Mark Schiefelbein).

A federal judge who ordered authorities to release a habeas corpus petitioner from detention, only to learn ICE immediately rearrested the Mexican national outside, said Wednesday that an immigration official and, “by extension,” the government were in “clear contempt” of court for roughly two weeks.

“In this immigration habeas case, the Court must decide whether, as to this technical point, Respondents violated a court order. Make no mistake: They did,” U.S. District Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney’s 15-page order said.

The Joe Biden-appointed jurist in Colorado said petitioner Ramon Quintero Alvarez “entered the United States with his mother” over “thirty years ago,” has lived the last dozen years in Wyoming and has two sons who are both American citizens.

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

“Although Mr. Quintero Alvarez faced arrests for certain criminal charges, the charges underlying his most recent arrest were ultimately dropped on April 24, 2026,” the judge said, referring to the reason for Quintero Alvarez’s detention going back to February.

Through a habeas petition, Quintero Alvarez challenged that detention as “unlawful,” but the government “failed to respond” on Oct. 27 with an argument for why he should remain in custody.

By Nov. 3, Sweeney explained, the government confirmed Quintero Alvarez was released on Oct. 27 but represented that he was “immediately re-detained” outside.

The judge, stunned that the “unlawfulness” of the “re-detention” wasn’t “obvious,” said she learned something at a hearing the next day that “should—and, in the Court’s opinion, must—shock any reader.”

More Law&Crime coverage: DOJ lawyer insists there’s ‘really not a legal dispute here’ while asking appeals court to reverse ‘entirely improper’ contempt order against ‘apologetic’ JAG lawyer

Nichole Black, an assistant field office director for ICE’s Enforcement and Removal Operations, testified that she believed the rearrest complied with the order because Quintero Alvarez had “some type of criminality,” as Deputy Field Office Director George Valdez instructed through Acting Field Office Director Nathan Rasper.

“Ms. Black ‘believed’ at the time of Mr. Quintero Alvarez’s release that simply releasing him into a public area before re-detaining him amounted to compliance with the Court’s prior order,” the judge said. “At the time of the November 4 hearing, Ms. Black maintained that belief. She was also aware of ‘approximately ten’ cases where ICE immediately re-detained habeas petitioners following their release pursuant to court orders.”

The judge blasted Rasper for trying to “throw [Black] under the proverbial bus for unconstitutional behavior that runs top to bottom,” taking ICE and other agency head respondents to task for the “ridiculous nature of the justification for their behavior.”

“Re-detaining someone immediately is hardly an effort to even ‘attempt to accomplish’ the Court’s order to release Mr. Quintero Alvarez. If anything, it is an effort to thwart his release. This is precisely the disobedient conduct that contempt proceedings contemplate, and words straight from the horse’s mouth are undoubtedly clear and convincing evidence that ICE and Respondents meet all the requirements for the Court to hold them in civil contempt,” the judge concluded.

However, the contempt, which lasted from Oct. 27 to Nov. 9, has already been purged.

On Nov. 9, Rasper’s representation in court that the immediate rearrest practice “ceased” was “the single thing that saves Ms. Black and Respondents” and “essentially cured” the contempt, Sweeney stated.

The post ICE offered ‘ridiculous’ excuse for rearresting man just released from detention and was in ‘clear contempt’ of court: Judge first appeared on Law & Crime.

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -

Most Popular

- Advertisment -
Share on Social Media