Before the Summer House Season 10 reunion even got underway, Kyle Cooke had serious questions regarding the timeline of when Amanda Batula and West Wilson actually got together.
The episode kicked off with Kyle interrupting one of Lindsay Hubbard’s In The City confessional interviews immediately after Amanda and West confirmed their relationship via social media on March 31. As they conferenced several of their castmates into a phone call while reading their Amanda and West’s joint statement for the first time live on camera, Lindsay aptly pointed out, “Now, it’s like, when did it start?”
Underscoring how Carl Radke had previously picked up on West being “touchy and handsy” with his wife, Kyle said, “Amanda tried to play it off last night like it’s only been happening for a month.” Mia Calabrese called “bulls–t” over speakerphone, claiming that Amanda and West had been together, “at minimum,” since the second week of January.
Kyle, meanwhile, theorized that the romance might’ve actually begun even before then. “I will say there were [blind items] going back to June 2025,” he declared. “I don’t know what Amanda and West can say to, like, recover.”
When did Amanda Batula and West Wilson start dating?
At the Summer House Season 10 reunion, Amanda and West confirmed they started dating in February 2026.
RELATED: West Wilson and Amanda Batula’s Relationship Timeline: Rumors, Confirmation & Reactions
Amanda Batula and West Wilson share more dating timeline details
More specifically, Amanda said that she and West shared their first kiss at the end of February, while the latter specified that the lip-lock occurred following a brunch they had with several cast members — including Kyle.
When host Andy Cohen inquired about who made the “first move” prior to the kiss, West revealed, “When we were out, I, like, kind of looked at Amanda, and I was like, ‘Am I f–kin’ crazy, or is there a little something going on here?”
As for when Amanda and West slept together for the first time, the former shared, “After the statement. I mean, not that night, but…”
Why Ciara Miller was skeptical of Amanda Batula and West Wilson’s timeline claims
In fact, the timeline of Amanda and West’s relationship was one of the first topics that Andy addressed with the group. For starters, he asked Ciara Miller when she initially suspected “something was going on” between West and Amanda, she named the specific date of January 17.
“I, like, went to call Amanda to invite her out to drinks with me and Mia, and her location was at West’s house,” Ciara explained. “And so, I had called, and she didn’t answer. And then [I] texted, and [she] didn’t answer.”
RELATED: West Wilson Addresses Amanda Batula “Timeline” Backstage at Summer House Reunion (EXCLUSIVE)
Amanda, for her part, interjected to clarify that she responded 30 minutes later, but as Ciara pointed out, her reply arrived only after Mia got involved and put them all in a group text. “I was like, hm, that’s weird. Why would she be at West’s house?” Ciara continued before Amanda cut her off to say, “Because West was there for me all summer and was checking in.”
Ciara swiftly reclaimed her time to pointedly ask, “And where was I?” Amanda answered, “You were also there for me,” before adding that West had simply asked her to get a drink and she’s only hung out with him twice. Amanda also insisted that she was not “discrediting” Ciara’s friendship or feelings, but she continued to defend herself, nonetheless.
“Oh my God, guess what? I had an awakening,” Amanda fired back. “I was living on my own, I’d separated from my ex, and I was trying to prioritize myself. … I’m also hanging out with other people. I was not just hanging out with West.”
Either way, Amanda and West eventually confessed that they “100 percent lied” to Ciara and the others when they denied, both publicly and privately, that there was anything romantic going on between them.
As you await the reunion’s continuation, go inside the full timeline of West and Amanda’s dating scandal, including the early rumors, their eventual confirmation, and the cast’s reactions.
