Sutton Stracke revealed where her relationship with Garcelle Beauvais stands now, about a year after their longtime friendship ended on the heels of Garcelle’s exit from The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills.
“The plain truth is this: I have lost a friend,” Sutton revealed during the RHOBH Season 15 Reunion Part 2. “I hope that one day we can reconcile or at least talk.”
“On Watch What Happens Live [with Andy Cohen], Garcelle said that she simply realized that she had given much more in your friendship than she got back,” Andy posed to Sutton during Part 2 of the reunion, as they unpacked what went wrong.
Producers then showed a flashback of Garcelle’s Oct. 23, 2025, WWHL appearance, in which the former RHOBH cast member stated of Sutton, “Not only [did she not] have my back, she also … never took accountability for it, and that hurt my feelings a lot.”
During the reunion, Sutton got her chance to respond to Garcelle’s claims. “I don’t know why she thinks that, to be honest. I would have done anything for her and those boys. Anything—and she knows that,” Sutton told Andy.
Sutton Stracke has a new guess as to why her friendship with Garcelle Beauvais ended
Still, Sutton offered up a theory. “I had one thought the other day,” Sutton added, recalling a moment from the RHOBH Season 14 reunion in which she called her “biggest surprise” from Season 14 being “that Erika [Jayne] and I got along so well.” Sutton believed that Garcelle had wanted her to say something about the moment Garcelle helped her bond with her mother, Reba.
RELATED: Sutton Stracke Sheds New Light on Her Fallout with Garcelle Beauvais: “It’s a Shame” (EXCLUSIVE)
However, Andy had a different thought. “I think the conjecture may have been that you said that after Erika had said Garcelle has been very boring and did nothing on the show,” he replied, hinting that Sutton took Erika’s side over Garcelle’s in their feud.
“My friendship with her was more than a reunion show,” Sutton concluded.
The RHOBH cast has theories about what happened between Sutton Stracke and Garcelle Beauvais
In case you need a refresher, things started to publicly unravel for the former besties when Garcelle refused to join the Season 14 reunion cast photo and declared she was “out” before walking off the reunion stage. Garcelle then unfollowed all her castmates, including Sutton.
At the start of RHOBH Season 15, Sutton shared she had “no idea” what happened to her friendship with Garcelle, calling the situation “very rough.”
During RHOBH Season 15, Sutton hit a rough patch with her pal Jennifer Tilly, who, in the heat of the moment, offered up her own theory as to what happened between Garcelle and Sutton. “I do believe that’s one of the reasons why Garcelle left, because it’s always all about Sutton,” Jennifer told Kyle Richards during the Jan. 15 episode. “It’s not about anybody else. … It’s just too much.”
During Part 2 of the Season 15 reunion, Jennifer apologized for adding fuel to the fire. “I should never have said those things to Kyle, and I was in a vulnerable moment,” she said. “I just really feel like Sutton is a very good friend to me. She has been there for me in really, really crucial moments in my life, and so, I apologize for saying that.”
RELATED: Jennifer Tilly Reveals Where She Stands With Garcelle Beauvais Today
Sutton, too, took accountability for her part in the matter. “I really do apologize for like barking at you. I really do. Because you’re the last person I would want to hurt,” she told Jennifer.
Check out the red carpet reunion between Garcelle and Kathy Hilton.
