Inset: Antwan Hayes (Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department). Background: N. Oxford St. in Indianapolis, Ind., where Kenneth Anthony Murff Jr. was shot (Google Maps).
An Indiana man who was a teenager when he fatally shot the brother of his ex-girlfriend”s new boyfriend will spend the next few decades behind bars.
Antwan Hayes, 20, pleaded guilty to murder in connection with the death of 23-year-old Kenneth Anthony Murff Jr. Hayes was 19 years old when he threatened to kill the next person his ex-girlfriend dated, then showed up at her new boyfriend’s home in Indianapolis, Indiana, during the early morning hours of Nov. 11, 2025. The woman, who had been trying to hide her new relationship from Hayes, arrived at the house with her boyfriend around 4 a.m.
Hayes then showed up about 10 minutes later and said, within earshot of the neighbors, “Open the front door before I kill somebody.”
When no one let Hayes inside the house, he fired several shots into a side window, hitting Murff. Murff was taken to the hospital in critical condition and later died from his injuries.
Police said Hayes and his ex-girlfriend fled the property in her car. She later said she left with Hayes because she was “confused and afraid.” Hayes went on the run after the shooting and turned himself in to police on Jan. 1.
Hayes and the woman had broken up months prior to the shooting, after which Hayes told her he would kill whoever she dated after him. The woman told police that she never expected Hayes to follow through on those threats.
Surveillance video captured Hayes walking around the house to the front door carrying a pistol with an extended magazine.
Hayes was charged with murder and burglary with a deadly weapon. As part of his plea agreement, the burglary charge was dismissed. On Nov. 6, a judge sentenced Hayes to 45 years in prison with credit for 309 days served.
